Well, as everyone else said, the blue colors on black-fusion.com is a bit confusing. Also, I would suggest using text instead of those images. Search engines don't see any content on that page and it would help search engine crawlers a lot by using text instead of images. The forum on the other hand matches the "image" of the website a lot more. Lots of good categories to choose from and a good memberbase is always good.
Index page confusing cause it's all one colour, make the links a different colour to differentiate them at least, make them match the forum But I think the forum theme alot
Odd, hope it goes back up, after seeing they're work I was considering getting a style made from them