You should enter, you have some fantastic designs in your portfolio I might hit you up for some logo designs for a couple of other sites I own.
Thanks guys for the entries... @ramakrishna - like the cartoon, but I want a white background for the logo. Maybe try to work the cartoon into it similar to what NRLmedia did. @jamess - linke I said in previous comments, Im not a fan of the tick. It looks like a logo template with Directory Critic next to it!
I normally (never) do logos, but I just couldn't resist. I tried to match your color scheme as best I could. I went for a list thing that represents both listing directories and rating them (critiquing), and did a checkbox to represent a positive rating, of course. Looking forward to hearing some feedback. Edit: I just read that you aren't a fan of the tick. Maybe you might like mine since it's not JUST a tick really? Just awaiting a response.
Thanks SasaVtec for the headsup. I request designers no to copy someone logoes that are already existing on net. It is too bad...believe on your creativity...If copied designs start winning the contests and what about really designers efforts and time? If prize money is given to a copied design then where will creativity stand?....
@zmaja: There are a lot of designs...I am thinking..and am comparing! Be patient... OK, ramakrishna, I like the circle better than the oval but I like it with Directory Critic on the outside of the circle. As the main text. AndrewR, Yeah, not a fan of the tick. Try working on a better pic/graphic zmaja - I like the thinner fonts, that font type doesn't really fit with the site. I like your graphic though. Keep em comin guys
Here is my entry. The image is an illustrator vector, so you can change it to any color that suits your site.