This has to be my favorite of your submissions! It's very unique and well thought out. It drew my attention the first time I saw it. I love it! Reminds me of Africa. I'm not sure if it fits with my niche, as I make my products from England, and people might assume it's African made like 'Black African Soap' which is now very popular. Thanks for all your work. You're very talented.
I have to say that your third entry is my favorite of your designs by far. You certainly have done your research and this shown in the detail. It looks very fitting of what I want to represent. It looks beautiful and elegant! I can imagine having this created into a stamp to put on the soap itself and on the packaging too. I love the small leaf above the 'a' on Natures Element and the circular design together. I'm really into this and your second design. Is it possible to have the third design, but with an option of the simplicity of the second? I can see the third looking great on the soap and second looking great on a banner or website if you know what I mean? I like the colours of the third better though. Your forth entry is also very elegant and stylish. I can easily imagine this on business cards. Not sure if the fourth one represents what I want though. The others certainly convey an air of homemade/natural.
I love this design! It simple and catches the eye easily. I like the colour theme you've used to show how versatile the design is. As I said I will be building a website etc from this logo so it's very good of you to show me a spectrum of choices. I'm not sure it screams natural soap/cosmetics though. It could come across like a financial business. What do you think?
This is similar to your first entry and all the nice things I said about that I would say about this. I like that you've given the option of having four flower shapes rather than three. The elements to me are Earth, Air, Fire, Water and Spirit. In this design four are represented which is great.
Thank you for entering the competition. Your design looks great! It is very clear and I like that you've included little soap bubbles. This is very cute. The design reminds me of 'Original Source' which is marketed as a more natural body wash product. Not sure if you've heard of it but it's very popular in the UK. It's not really a natural product though . I do like this as it stands out but I don't think it really emphasises the 'element' part of my name. What do you think?
This is super cute! I don't know if you're slightly psychic but this is very similar to an early design I made when I first started thinking about setting up a small business making natural homemade soaps a couple of years ago. I'm not sure if this style is the way I want to go now but it's still very much in my consideration. Thanks for taking the time to enter.
Hi thanks for entering. I love this design too. I like the simplicity and clarity of it. It's not complicated and I think customers will appreciate that. I do worry that it's very similar to the inspiration I posted, or maybe too simplistic. I'm not sure. I'm still absolutely considering it.
Thanks for the detailed feedback, it was really helpful to understand what exactly you want. I have tweaked my design according to your feedback, also incorporated stamp design for web and stationery. You can use stamp on soap and for packaging and use the other logo for web and printing purpose. Also if you like #2 font I can edit that as well just tried to use same font as in stamp logo so they will look related to each other. All demos are presented.
Ok, having seen all the submissions, and offering feedback on each one. I think I've found my winner. muddy786!!! This submission is my favorite. I love the design so much and I believe you've shown the most passion and design ability for my requirements. I can't thank you enough for all your work on this and you truly deserve the praise. You're very talented! Thank you so much to everyone else that took the time to submit their entries. You're all stars in your own right and I have commented on each one and liked all your posts! I loved all your designs in different ways but muddy786 managed to fulfill everything I wanted and more. Please consider this contest now closed. muddy786 I will now PM you for payment.