For a tool to manage daily forum posting activities, what features would you like to have? 1) find right threads across many forum sites 2) track participation 3) change signature files across forum sites 4) find right forums. Or there's no need for such a tool at all?
It's not that there is no use for a tool... It's just that people don't want a robot posting for them. Now a helpful tool would be a program which browses forums and picks out threads with specific titles. I'm a copywriter... So I'd love to find anything with copywriting in the title. Know what I mean?
If you look forum writing I noticed that places such as odesk and Freelances have people who will do the posting in forums. I'm not sure how this works because surly they are putting down their own opinions.
Are forums becoming what blogs used to be (except now instead of guest posts, they do signature posts on multiple forums)? The thing is if that becomes excessive Google will swoop down like a hawk and penalize forums for allowing signatures. Can happen. So, definitely not "change signature files across forum sites".
Would it work better if a tool finds all recent threads about "copywriting" and place all threads on one page so you can easily see which ones you'll be interested. There're tens and usually hundreds of forums related to any giver keyword, it is unpractical to browse. But those are very basic features, the tool we've built http://www.soengaging.com/ does much more.
Forum signature links doesn't offer much or any SEO value even before guest posting gets popular. A signature link is like a business card in online world. They do generate traffic sometimes. So a tool around SEO is probably a not a good idea.
I would not like to see a Forum Marketing Tool. From the first day that some self appointed Guru taught about forum marketing, most forums have been inundated with a lot of junk posts, Software like that would take forum use from difficult to unbearable al
But a tool that helps forum users do a better job and save time would help, right? Automation is a bad idea. I totally agree.