A good Contest Holder should give feedback on all entries, so that no ones time is wasted, I had faith in the CH as he had some good feedback, but seeing and experiencing that he does not give feedback to any of the designs, I lost faith, I fear this might end up in the Digitalpoint No winner declared and/or paid Contest.
The CH needs to work things out with the designers through giving his feedback or comments. Without that, this contest wouldn't be effective and will only result undesired outcomes. I think it's unfair to us designers who exerted much effort and just expects a simple feedback of our work. We all want to win this contest. One deserves to win, and by win I mean in a fair and equal manner. -DrD
This is making me think. If you think it's fair then you can put it. The problem is that not everyone has the same thoughts on his designs as you do. Personally, I prefer send designs for SUCH contests via PM simply because a big prize is involved and I have made something which should match this prize. I am sure there are better designs than mine but in any case if I win, I will post it here and if I don't win, I can simply use the idea for another logo because I am pretty sure people will look for this style. Now if I post it here, I lose, I am 100% sure someone will copy the idea and I will see it somewhere 1 day There is nothing like you trust your designs are good or not. There is something called Privacy. I better go for the Privacy in my case. However, I do agree that the CH should give feedback to all to make it "really" fair for each and everyone. Good Luck Everyone
I sent feedback early where said that we simply do not like most of entries. We can not explain why we do not like it. We just do not like it! Or should I write "we do not like it" to each post here? F5DesignStudio PM quite good concept today too. Feizar, I definitely tell the winner and we pay $500.
Many people ask me to post F5DesignStudio entry! Hope he doesn't mind http://s1123.photobucket.com/albums/l556/JasonTwisted1/?action=view¤t=digfileNewconcept.jpg
Hello, Posting here my PM'ed entry with some minor touchups: Mirror Link: http://s15.postimage.org/nbh9a1re3/Dig_File3_copy.jpg