So are you asking which one would I choose if I HAD to make a choice? I would actually choose the forums because, long term, they are the ones that are most likely to bring me traffic. They may not be the best in terms of improving my search engine profile, but they are more likely to generate traffic than having three random links.
from a backlinks perspectve, I was asking which backlinking method would work better in improve the site in the SERPs, getting a link from a seperate c class website with a related keyword in the domain name and relevant content. (This is what Jeff Johnson advocates to get top rankings) and I have seen sites (which I am competing against doing this aswell) but want to hear from those who have done it and what the results were like if anyone would be kind enough to share that information.
I would probably go with the 3 links from blogs. I had a forum profile blast done and it didn't seem to help much.
In my experience, I go with quantity. I've tried the expensive high PR links with no results. My websites move well with hundreds of low or no PR backlinks. Don't waste your money on high PR backlinks unless you want to get hundreds. I love forum profiles and posts as long as the forum is indexed in Google. They do work.
The idea of relevant to your blog links is overrated if you ask me. I know many people think that you should mostly get links from blogs that are relevant to your content but in my opinion that's just a myth. Go with the forum profiles.