http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/wor...Factor-TV-attack-hardline-Muslim-clerics.html Is she good? Bad? If she is bad, should she be punished? If so, how? Is she a good Muslim? Is she helping or hurting the worldwide Muslim cause? You obviously don't hear about practicing Muslims like her speaking out like this very often, which makes her a bit of a rarity. I certainly have my opinions on the matter, but I am way more interested in what the practicing Muslims on this forum think of her.
I'm aware of what she did. I was asking for Muslim opinions on what she did. My original questions below.
Actual she says a poem, what the poem i dont know, it was written its against Islamic preaches, how can i ans without read it, But till now i am proud on her, she atleas prove to the west world that a Muslim woman in Burqa or Sakaaf can do any thing.
Here is the text of her poem, in short "I have seen evil from the eyes of the subversive fatwas in a time when what is lawful is confused with what is not lawful; When I unveil the truth, a monster appears from his hiding place; barbaric in thinking and action, angry and blind; wearing death as a dress and covering it with a belt [referring to suicide bombing]; He speaks from an official, powerful platform, terrorizing people and preying on everyone seeking peace; the voice of courage ran away and the truth is cornered and silent, when self-interest prevented one from speaking the truth." Also, could you answer the questions about the message as well as the messenger(if the two opinions are different).
ehmm... you mean she can only complain that bigoted ignorant and primitive men made her put this tent on herself that if she had the choice she probably wouldn't?
Its pretty impressive that not one Muslim on this forum has the guts to comment on this woman's comments, one way, or the other. I guess we can lump them in with the rest who are sending her death threats.
She is a very courageous woman to stand up to all the extremists scumbags. I am really happy that the public has voted her to win the contest and hopefully she will be safe. All Muslim man and woman should stand up and denounce the terrorists but unfortunately this almost never happenes. Muslims in this forum are very quick to say that Islam doesn't allow the killing of innocent people but that only happened when Muslims are labeled as terrorist. I have never seen a single thread that a Muslim in this forum has started to condemn terrorism.
Very true. I have considered that it may be more from fear of their fellow Muslims than hatred of the west. It is a legitimate concern.
check out the second post again and again lolz,(may be you guys do like this) we had thousands of time state here that Islam does not Support Terrorims, even Quran states in clear words "one who kill innocent, its mean he killes the whole humanity"
Sometime some people need a topic to discuss and Islam here is a good choice, so if you bang your head saying same thing repeatedly still they could not hear because they are not looking for what you are tying to say, they would love to hear which is something against Islam
It seems that you are paying more attention to the fact that she's a woman, than the words and meaning of her poetry. This poem is not an endorsement of islamic dress, or the burqa. In fact, she's stated she would prefer not wear a face covering... The poetry is not about showing, or proving anything to the Western world either. It's about extremist muslim clerics who create subversive fatwas "when what is lawful is confused with what is not lawful." "When I unveil the truth"...(as in challenging the fatwa) "a monster appears from his hiding place; barbaric in thinking and action, angry and blind; wearing death as a dress and covering it with a belt [referring to suicide bombing];" (as in those that challenge, are threatened and intimidated, this is what is happening to her now with death threats.) He speaks from an official, powerful platform, terrorizing people and preying on everyone seeking peace; the voice of courage ran away and the truth is cornered and silent, when self-interest prevented one from speaking the truth."...(I think she is speaking here of extremist muslim clerics, and that self interest, and fear prevents many from speaking up.)
Actually they had much interest in Islam and Muslim peoples, Islam attract every one thats why they are much active in Islamic topic than their own how much i proud to be a Muslim
It is true that Islam attracts everyone. But is for the wrong reasons. If you think that people here are active in Islam topics because they are in love with the teachings of Islam you need to adjust your brain.
Then they should had no problem with out rules and regulations at all!! weather this woman should be punished or not its not your consort, if you really love humanity then save lifes of those who are killed by your own hands in Iraq, Lebnon, Gaza, Pakistan, Afghanistan etc
Did you tell everyone that those who don't believe in alahmohamad are considered guilty and therefore they can be killed? Oh, did you forget that little piece of information or just inconvenient like al gore? Wait, didn't those places already have people dying daily? Shoot, just another inconvenient truth.
I wish i can also read such kind of stuff too, you guys has extra ordinary knowledge of Islam (which are basically not the part of Islam), WOW
That was very brave of her, unfortunately they will have to kill her soon for insulting the great cleric of islam. It is pointless to even ask this pro-barbaric's their opinions, they will just deny every thing and blame it on the juice.
Amazing that we have gotten to 17 posts on this thread and still not one Muslim has had the balls to answer the questions originally posted. Vebtools claims he has in this post: But the text from his answer is: Which does not answer even one of the questions. The questions are simple. What do you think of the woman and her message? If her message is bad, what should be done to her? If her message is right, are you willing to publicly say so? If your only answer is, "More Muslim bashing" or some other change of topic, go create your own thread. This topic of this thread could not have been more clearly stated. ANSWER THE QUESTIONS.