Wow Jeezy that was kind of uncalled for. You have no idea what someone is capable of. Besides, these are two completely different styles. I know I personally spent maybe 30 minutes on my characters because he asked for concepts. Tab getting a lot of recognition because he's the only one who submitted a final design and I'll say it is pretty good, but the guy didn't ask for everyone to do that. Dorarpol that is hillarious and def crazy!!
Having used both Cameo and Tababongshi for designs in the past, I would never like to say one is better than the other. They both have different styles, there should be no mistaking either of their talents. Saying one is better than the other is, apart from being very rude, just not very constructive. I also agree that you can't judge somebody from a sketch, not at all. Just like you would never judge a final logo design or web site from a sketch. Once the final rendering is complete, the change can be massive. I would personally love to have the mascot skills of either of them!
I feel like I want to thank some people who is supporting my work on this thread...but I also would like to admire CameoAnderson for not being a quitter, he's one tough contender and I hope you all can see that. We're all just part of this contest so I suggest that we all respect each others work...thanks to all who likes my work but as you all know...there's no winner yet so we're all just on the same level here...so keep on posting our works as best as we can to win...rather than commenting on each others post...cheers everyone
Eevn though tab kinda said let's quit commenting on each other's posts, I have to do one more thing... Dave... that new Memvy design is AWESOME. I LOVE what whoever you hired to do that, did for that character. He's spectacular
I don't mean to come across as a jackass, but I believe the foot on the right side of the image is a bit too large IMO. Lol as you stated in the bolded text, we all have our own opinions, and in my opinion Tab's was nicer. That, however doesn't mean you suck as an artist. Sorry if it came across that way. Again, I didn't mean to come across as a jackass, I was simply voicing my opinion. Actually, I really liked Tab's sketch way before he finalized it. We all know he didn't ask for anything, it just goes to show how much people liked the sketch. I agree, CameoAnderson is definately a good artist, and has the right spirit, she still entered after seeing your work. Something some of us wouldn't do. But as stated earlier, IMO I like your sketch more.
Well I have things to say but I'm just gonna not. I think that would be the best way to go. I don't think it matters what nayone thinks about any of our art at this point. I think the CH bailed.
I've already apologized lol. As I mentioned I didn't mean to come across as rude. Anyways good luck and hope that this dude didn't really bail, I hate when CH's do that.
THats' why I got rid of that post cause I realize... I don't need to drag it out. I just didn't like it that two people went out of their way to tell me I couldn't live up to Tab. It was okay that my entries weren't as well liked, but I was disappointed to be told I couldn't do better without even a look at my gallery . But hey it's the art world, and I'm sure someone's going to say way worse lol. I hope the CH doesn't back out as well but he's already 3 days overdue. Tab is concerned as well. There are a lot of REALLy fun entries to this contest
Hey Cameo, I really apologize for what I said, I didn't mean it to come out like that, Your drawing skills are excellent, don't take this the wrong way but the coloring is what throws it off a little bit, have you try cell shading/coloring? Here's an example http://yondaime-sama.deviantart.com/art/Cell-Shade-Coloring-Tutorial-43032432 Try it, you will be amazed by the way your sketches will look at the end!
A favorite the tutorial. I'm going to play around with it tomorrow. Thank you for the link. And I'm glad to know you didn't really mean it the way it came off. I kinda wanted everyone to understand that these were just concepts, not finished things, that I was uploading, becuase the contest holder seemed to want just concepts. I can do way better I swear Tab showed off with a pretty much finished piece The only thing I would have changed was the eyes. Anyhow, this was a fun contest to enter.
So considering the CH was at DP here today and didn't bother replying in the thread is it safe to assume no one is going to win? BTW, a lot of great designs in this thread.
yep it is sad. I stopped posting anything else in this thread because I did not see any posts from the CH. He originally said that he wanted something by the First I think. Well unfortunately it looks like he has bailed on us.
It sucks, but he hasn't posted since the first, right? Maybe he's still scraping the cash together. Sorry I pulled you into this contest Cameo!
TK It's okay. It happens. I might be able to sell those characters to someone else, you never know. And whether or not anlyone buys that furry guy, I like him so much, I'm gonna finish him up and put him in my gallery