Which banner.... 1 or 2 ???

[billabong]

Hi guys
Ive just made 2 small banners, which are similar, woulld just like your input on which you think is the best!!!!
Number 1.
http://img451.imageshack.us/img451/5121/logo49he.png (http://www.ecampsite.co.uk)

Number 2.
http://img211.imageshack.us/img211/7809/logo57yu.png (http://www.ecampsite.co.uk)

Cheers
Craig

[Crazy_Rob]

Number 2 all the way!

[Smyrl]

I agree with Rob.

Shannon

[Crazy_Rob]

It might look better if you make the tent opening a little darker.

[wrmineo]

Yes, a darker shade on the tent opening and you've got a winner with #2 IMO.

[billabong]

http://img451.imageshack.us/img451/5959/logo61tx.png (http://www.ecampsite.co.uk)

is that one better???

[lorien1973]

I'd make your banner closer to your on-site logo. Make it consistent if you are going to do a graphic

[Sorror]

Badly the second one.

[maldives]

voted for the second.

[Contentczar]

number 2 looks good, so i voted for it, number 1 confused me a bit

[billabong]

thank you for the feedback!!! Im def gonna go with that one!!! cheers

[Lpspider]

Well, I'm not the majority, but I voted for number one.

[angelfire]

I voted for no. 2. The first one confused me, I thought it was a mountain.
Well good luck :D

[texisman]

I vote for the first. It looks more alive. Look's like they've got a light on in the tent. It also looks more 3d to me.

[honey]

Number 2 looks better.

[EGS]

Number 2, I'd say. I can't even see number 1, but judging from the earlier expressions...#2 is the most understandable. ;)

[blakekr]

#2. I like it better without the gradient inside.

[josephine]

i like the 2nd more.

[Lpspider]

way to revive a thread after a month and a half. :/