Price Comparison store logo - $30

[mikebrad0927]

I need a better logo for whichischeaper.com (http://www.whichischeaper.com), a price comparison site that has just launched. I'd like for the logo to be 2.0ish but still go with the general color scheme of the site, however, I would be willing to adjust the current colors for the right design.

Please post responses here and I will choose a winner by Friday June 15th @ 7pm Eastern Time.

Winner will be paid $30 via paypal.

[james1988]

http://tableaux.co.uk/show_comp.php?id=95d95049&name=whichischeaper.jpg

Please tell me what you think.

[onixz100]

Here is my entry!

I hope you like it!

http://img236.imageshack.us/img236/4752/whichischeapercopylq4.png

[mikebrad0927]

Two nice entries, thank you.

James1988 - I like the watermark in the background but sort of think the font needs a little more, it's sort of plain (like the one I made). I'd like to see it with glossier lettering.

onixz100 - I also like the watermark in yours but not the scale so much. Also, see if you can spice up the font a bit.

Thank you both, I look forward to seeing your work again.

[gfxmachines]

is this contest is stil open????

[mikebrad0927]

Yes, this contest will be open for a few more days. I will pick a winner on Friday.

[onixz100]

I could remove the scale, but I put it there to resemble comparison. I still have the .psd so it's all good, but I am not sure how it would look without the scale.
Along with this, I don't know what type of font would make the banner better without destroying the general feel of the website.

Making it 2.0, glossy or sci-fi'ish would destroy the feel of your website since your website is more of a professional and elegant look. Making 2.0 type of banners at the type would remove the sense of "professionalism".

That's my opinion. If you want me to remove it but keep it generally the same, just tell me :D ^^

[Solid_Nuts]

i agree with onixz100, making a 2.0ish logo with your site would take it out of style because your site isnt 2.0 :)

[mikebrad0927]

Fair enough, I appreciate the comments. I thought that I could pull something off but I just slapped up a glossy logo and you guys were right, it takes away more than it gives.

onyxz100 - keep the scale, lose the slogan "find the best deals" and let me go from there.

everyone else - please ignore my comments on a glossy logo

[ArMouR]

I would like to try, will have something in done soon

[mac_crazy]

Here's my entry:

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1169/541258817_0e8087792c_o.jpg

[xpressions]

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y185/nemagazine/whichischeaper.png

different concept/colors:

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y185/nemagazine/whichischeaper2.png

[ArMouR]

Here's my sample

http://www.risharde.com/uploads/whichischeaper/whichischeaper-new1.jpg

[mikebrad0927]

xpressions - i like the second concept, any way to make it fit with the color scheme. Maybe use a brown similar to the nav bar instead of the red.

[mikebrad0927]

armour - i like where you are going with this but it just seems a bit too much brown/yellow. Is it possible to see something like this with a bluish header?

[mac_crazy]

any feedback on mine, mikebrad?

[onixz100]

Hey MikeBrad, Here is the picture without the slogan. I personally found the slogan bad too, I just thought you really required one.

http://img253.imageshack.us/img253/4084/whichischeapercopyux3.jpg

There are several subtle changes :) Hopefully you noticed them. I made the writing a bit more elegant and made it so the background wouldn't be so boring on the right side.

[AddictedtoFate]

http://i89.photobucket.com/albums/k220/addictedtofate/jpg-73.jpg
Feedback appreciated,
-ATF

[mikebrad0927]

mac crazy - not exactly what I'm looking for

onixz100 - I totally agree with you and I liked the "Browse, Compare, Save" slogan, I just wanted you to get rid of the "find the best deals" slogan and vertically center the word "cheaper".

AddictedtoFate - looks good, may offer more feedback in the morning.

[james1988]

http://tableaux.co.uk/show_comp.php?id=a07921809&name=whichischeaper2.jpg

[xpressions]

Thank you for the feedback. Here's a revised version:

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y185/nemagazine/whichischeap.png

[gfxmachines]

Am in.. will submit soon..

[mikebrad0927]

xpressions - looking good, but could this work with a blue header? Maybe a thin outline of the larger blue tag. I like it.

gfx - looking forward to it.

[crowquill]

My attempt

http://img521.imageshack.us/img521/6835/whichischeaperis3.jpg

[onixz100]

Roar, a complete redo :) Hope you like it, I do!

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/3958/whichischeapersw4.jpg

[james1988]

http://tableaux.co.uk/show_comp.php?id=e75602342&name=whichischeaperlogo2.jpg

[AddictedtoFate]

Thanks for the feedback, would you like to see anything changed?
-ATF

[mikebrad0927]

atf - no changes at this time, thank you.

onix - I like your header, this contest is going to be tough to decide.

[james1988]

what about mine?

[crowquill]

atf - no changes at this time, thank you.

onix - I like your header, this contest is going to be tough to decide.

No feedback provided for my entry (post sl.no.24).
http://forums.digitalpoint.com/showpost.php?p=3431950&postcount=24

[Xangular]

Please leave feedback.

http://www.freewebs.com/bizhostz/wc2.jpg

[Ariestoteles]

ok, will drop my entry too.. :)

[PluT0]

Here my design... feedback pls.

[xpressions]

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y185/nemagazine/whichischeap2.png

[hosters]

here's 1
http://i208.photobucket.com/albums/bb227/hosterphotos/WHICHCHEAPER.jpg

[ahughes]

I like AddictedtoFate's the best :O

[tarponkeith]

Please leave feedback.

http://www.freewebs.com/bizhostz/wc2.jpg

I'm just a spectator, but I like it

[AddictedtoFate]

Thank You :)
-ATF

I like AddictedtoFate's the best :O

[Xangular]

I'm just a spectator, but I like it


Thankyou very much.

[mikebrad0927]

Hey everyone, thanks for the great entries. If I didn't get a chance to offer feedback, please forgive me, it's been a hectic week to say the least. After carefully looking at the designs, it was a really close race between three designs but ultimately, I can only have one design for the site.

Onixz100's design just seemed to fit the best into the current site and they are the winner of this contest.

Onixz, I've sent you a pm.

Everyone else, thank you very much.