Review Rating Images

[Sleepy_Sentry]

I'm starting a reviews section on my website and have made a few images to rate the items I review. Let me know what you think of them. My goal when designing them was to have them look very professional.

http://www.pcfastlane.com/onethumbup.gifhttp://www.pcfastlane.com/twothumbsup.gif

http://www.pcfastlane.com/onethumbdown.gifhttp://www.pcfastlane.com/twothumbsdown.gif

I plan on using one of the top four images in addition to a the star (with the number of stars the product receives of course) for each of my reviews. You can see the star in my other post (there is a limit of 4 images per post).

[giraph]

I think it would look better if you took the "one thumb up" text off. It's easy to see the rating from the picture behind it, and seems unnecessary.

[m93rd]

like the pics

[ludwig]

are they gonna be this big??? it takes too much space

[AnaB]

Yes they are a little too big, I'd also perhaps change the background colour (but thats just me), remove the one thumbs up and "Pc Fastlane" can be a little smaller, I mean it doesnt have to be a Huge text for people to see it.

[KingofClick]

something more minimal would be nice maybe use arrows? I like the colors though!

[slickricky]

Just being honest, if you were going for professional, they don't really work. That inner bevel looks off somehow, and the thumbs (hands) would look a lot better without the drop shadow, and integrated better into the button.

Just my humble opinion.

[hfweb]

Hello,

I tried to see these images, however they seem to be a broken link.

Regards

Sorry for making a reply to such an old post, i was too far back on the list :)